More in Bid'ah & Innovations
MUJLISUL ULAMA OF S.A.
PO Box 3393
Port Elizabeth
6056, South Africa
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
1
THE MERRYMAKING CONFERENCE
Scholars or so-called scholars from about 50 countries
had congregated in Istanbul, Turkey for a three day
function of futility to plot a universal Islamic Calendar
and a single global zone, and to do away with moon-
sighting as commanded by Rasulullah (Sallallahu alayhi
wasallam). Promoting this kufr, Mr. Mehmet Gormez,
the president of Turkey’s state-run Presidency of
Religious Affairs, said:
“There has been a misconception or disregard for
scientific facts in the Islamic world. In this day and age,
when people can travel to the moon and observe the
movements of the sun and moon second by second, in
this age of major scientific developments, it was wrong
to disregard these developments and insist on observing
the new moon with the naked eye by climbing up
mountains. God and the prophet tell us to acquire
knowledge and use it.”
In this flotsam observation, the western bootlicker, Mr.
Gormez has demonstrated his stupidity as far as the
Shariah is concerned. The command to acquire
Knowledge is for obedience to Allah and His Rasool. It
is to be equipped for following the Shariah which Allah
Ta’ala has revealed, perfected and completed more than
fourteen centuries ago. The objective of Knowledge is
not to fabricate another man-made ‘shariah’ by
westernized bootlickers such as the conglomerate of
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
2
morons who had gathered in Istanbul for another
merrymaking conference of futility in which millions
were squandered whilst millions of Muslims destitute
are languishing in grinding poverty, squalor and jahaalat
all over the globe.
The Shariah does not require climbing up mountains to
sight the hilaal as the bootlicker avers. Yes, Allah Ta’ala
has commanded that the hilaal be seen with the naked
eye. This is the fundamental principle for determining
the commencement of the Islamic month. In the
sustainment of this Divine principle, all scientific
developments will be incumbently disregarded. Nothing
can override the Shariah. The conference of moron
‘scholars’ will not succeed in their stupid endeavours to
set aside what the Shariah commands.
There is a need for Muslim global activity to alleviate
the sufferings of the discarded refugees, boat migrants,
and the millions of ignorant Muslim children growing
up as kuffaar and being weaned off Islam by a variety of
inimical, sinister and satanic forces. There is no need for
a global zone nor a need to plot a universal Islamic
calendar which never were Islamic objectives since the
inception of Islam. The idea of a global zone and a
unified or one Islamic calendar for the entire Muslim
world is not only nonsensical, it is also satanic. It is
shaitaan who involves all these moron ‘scholars’ in
futile escapades under a deceptive ‘islamic’ tag. Whilst
the entire Muslim world is up in flames, these obese,
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
3
useless morons engage in merrymaking and squandering
the Ummahs’s money on satanic futility.
The plot of a universal calendar and the conspiracy to
scuttle the Shariah’s Waajib moon-sighting principle
will fail miserably. The juhala of this futile conference
will not succeed in their satanically motivated plot.
The concept of a global Ramadhaan or a global Eid, that
is, the beginning of Ramadhaan and the celebration of
Eid to be on the same day in every nook and cranny of
the world is a stupid haraam concept which has no truck
with the Shariah.
It is of imperative importance to first and fundamentally
understand that the Shariah is not an ever-changing
concept nor has it atrophied. The Shariah is not an
evolutionary process which may be subjected to the
vagaries of the wildly fluctuating opinions of liberal
‘scholars’. The Shariah’s propensity for flexibility is
securely fettered to its principles stemming from the
Qur’aan and Sunnah. This principled flexibility
proscribes unbridled opinion which operates beyond the
parameters of Shar’i principles.
The attempt by the morons to scuttle the principle of
Rooyat (seeing the moon with the eyes) is kufr. It is an
attempt to undermine the Shariah. This principle of
Rooyat is not the effect of opinion. It is a divine decree.
It was ordered by Rasulullah (Sallallahu alayhi
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
4
wasallam) himself. It is an inviolable principle which
cannot be put up for dissection and mutilation by a
world full of moron ‘scholars’ whose profession has
become conferences of futility and merrymaking.
On the contrary, the Shariah was handed down by Allah
Ta’ala via the agency of the Risaalat of Muhammadur
Rasulullah (Sallallahu alayhi wasallam) as a perfect and
complete Code of Life to cater for the entire world of
Muslims in all exigencies. Negating the idea of there
being scope for submitting the Shariah to re-
interpretation and mutilation by bootlicking and
bootlegging ‘scholars’ of the nafs and scholars for
dollars, the Qur’aan Majeed states:
“This Day have I perfected for you your Deen, and
completed for you My Favour, and have chosen for you
Islam as the Deen.”
It is inconceivable and vastly stupid to understand that
despite the perfection and completion of the Deen with
its Shariah by Allah Azza Wa Jal, the issues of
Ramadhaan and Eid would have been left ambiguous to
remain undecided, and that even fourteen centuries later
there exists no clarity on these vital issues. The Ummah
has been observing Ramadhaan and Eid since the era of
Rasulullah (Sallallahu alayhi wasalam). Islam had ruled
half of the globe for centuries. But there were no stupid
moves to plot a single or universal Ramadhaan or Eid.
All countries, cities, towns, villages and communities
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
5
acted according to the Waajib command of Rasulullah
(Sallallahu alayhi wasallam) to physically sight the
moon and proceed with their acts of Ibaadaat of
Ramadhaan, Eid, etc. This attempt by the wayward
‘scholars’ who congregated stupidly in Turkey and also
by some other juhala from time to time, are the effects
of westernization and of the enemies of Islam and of
shaitaan who keeps these bootlicking ‘scholars’
embroiled in stupidities whilst the Muslim world is
aflame.
If there was any merit in the plot of a universal calendar,
there would most certainly have been strong indication
in the Hadith. Rasulullah (Sallallahu alayhi wasallam)
and the Sahaabah would not have overlooked it. On the
contrary, we find in the Hadith the exact opposite of
what the morons are contemplating and plotting. The
Sahaabah had in fact negated the concept of a global
Ramadhaan/Eid. Celebrating Eid on different days is a
valid Islamic practice substantiated by the Amal of the
Sahaabah. The following narration confirms this fact
and explicitly debunks the concept of a global
Ramadhaan/Eid:
"Kuraib narrates that Ummul Fadhl Bintil Harrith
sent him on an errand to Muaawiyah in Shaam.
He said:
‘I went to Shaam and fulfilled her requirement
and while I was still in Shaam the hilaal of
Ramadhaan appeared over me. Thus, I saw the
hilaal on the night of Friday. Then towards the
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
6
end of the month I came to Madinah and
Abdullah lbn Abbaas questioned me. He then
spoke about the hilaal and said:
‘Did you (i.e. the people in Shaam) see the
hilaal?’
I said: ‘We saw it on the night of Friday.’
He said: ‘Did you see it?’
I said: ‘Yes, and the people saw it and fasted.
Muaawiyah too fasted.’
He (Ibn Abbaas) said: ‘But, we saw it on the
night of Saturday. Therefore, we shall continue to
fast until we complete thirty days or we see it (i.e.
the hilaal at the end of the 29th day)."
(Sahihul Muslim)
Rejecting the idea of a false unity - a unity based on
deviation from Shar’i principles and teachings – Hadhrat
Ibn Abbaas (Radhiyallahu anhu) reinforced the principle
of Rooyat-e-Hilaal (Sighting the moon with the naked
eye) as the determinant for commencing Ramadhaan and
celebrating Eid. And, the Sahaabah in Madinah did not
object to this Ruling of Hadhrat Abdullah Bin Abbaas
(Radhiyallahu anhu). He emphasized that the fast in
Madinah would continue until either the hilaal was
sighted at the end of the 29th day or after fasting a full 30
days.
If the stupid idea of global ‘eid’/global ‘ramadhaan’ had
any validity, this eminent Aalim among the Sahaabah
would not have ignored the sighting in Damascus, and
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
7
confirmation by the highest authority of the Islamic
World, the Khalifah, Hadhrat Muaawiyah (Radhiyallahu
anhu).
The information of the hilaal sighting and confirmation
was delivered most reliably to Hadhrat Ibn Abbaas
(Radhiyallahu anhu), but he issued the verdict that the
people of Madinah would go by their own sighting, not
the sighting of Damascus. This debunks the corrupt idea
of a global calendar/Ramadhaan/Eid. There is simply no
merit and no goodness and no reward in the stupid
haraam concept which the bootlicking ‘scholars’ are
abortively and laboriously attempting to hoist on the
Ummah with all the hot air they are puffing. There is
absolutely no incumbency on the people of one city or
zone to accept the sighting of another city. If the news of
one place is conveyed reliably, and if there is
convenience in its acceptance, its permissibility is not
denied. But hoisting the sighting of one place on to
another as an incumbent Shar’i tenet is satanic, stupid
and haraam. In fact, the most convenient method is to
adhere to the original Command and for all countries,
cities, towns, and villages to regulate their own
Ramadhaan and Eid affairs.
The idea of ‘unity’ based on a global Eid is moronic and
the plot of western bootlicking scholars for dollars. All
five Salaat are performed at different times in a million
places inhabited by Muslims. Such differences do not
give rise to disunity. Disunity stems from sin,
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
8
disobedience and abandonment of the teaching of the
Shariah. Disunity is not the effect of observing the
Commands of Allah Ta’ala. And, He has commanded
that Ramadhaan and Eid must commence with the actual
sighting of the hilaal, not with scientific calculations and
whatever the scientists, astronomers and bootlickers say.
Explicitly debunking the views of the astronomers and
scientists on these issues, the Fuqaha have ruled:
The following narration further strengthens the claim
that the sighting of the hilaal is essential and in the event
of no sighting being reliably reported, thirty days will
apply:
"Muhammad Bin Ziyaad narrates: ‘I heard Abu
Hurairah saying: Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi
wasallam) said:
‘Fast at its sighting and end the fasting at its
sighting. If then the moon becomes hidden on
you (on account of weather conditions), then
count thirty (days)."
"Count or enumerate thirty days" said Rasulullah
(sallallahu alayhi wasallam) in the event the hilaal is not
sighted at the end of the 29th day. There is no mention
and no instruction to resort to astronomy and the birth of
the hilaal for the determination of the Islamic months.
Imaam Nawawi (rahmatullah alayhi) states in his
Sharhul Muslim in the exposition of the statement:
“The meaning that it is the calculation of the
astronomers is not valid."
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
9
Imaam Shaafi further states:
"There is no substance in the statement of the
astronomer (in so far as the hilaal is concerned).
Fasting does not become obligatory with it nor is
it (fasting) permissible (with the calculation of
the astronomer)."
(Irshaadus Saari of Qustulaani)
In this regard, Durrul Mukhtaar states:
“The statement of the astronomers (regarding the
birth of the moon) is of no validity even if they
are uprighteous. . .
In Al-Wahbaaniyah it is said:
“The statements of the astronomers have no
effect (i.e. do not make incumbent fasting or
ending the fasting)."
In Shaami, the following appears:
"According to Ijma' (consensus) there is no
recognition for the statements of the astronomers.
It is not permissible for the astronomer to act
according to his calculation (i.e. he should neither
commence Ramadhaan nor end Ramadhaan on
the basis of his calculations)."
Scientific information and astronomical determinations
regarding the phases of the moon were known many
centuries ago. Astronomy is an old science. The early
Astronomy is an old science. The early Muslims were
aware of this science. However, the calculations of
astronomy were never adopted by the Ummah for the
purpose of determining the Islamic months since this
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
10
determination is not based on the birth of the moon or
the existence of the moon in any sphere or in any
particular stage in its orbital movement. It is a known
and an undeniable fact that the moon is always present
and existing in some position or stage in its orbit. Shar'i
laws do not concern with calculations which are beyond
the scope and means of the overwhelming majority of
mankind. Islam has, therefore, fixed the principle – the
simple principle – of SIGHTING the hilaal. This
principle is capable of adoption by all mankind,
wherever people happen to be. Therefore, in so far as the
Islamic months are concerned the existence and birth of
the moon have no substance. Sighting the hilaal and in
the event of this not being possible, the thirty days rule
will apply. While astronomical tables may be accepted
for mundane purposes, these are unacceptable for the
purpose of determining the Islamic months, not because
of unreliability, but because Rasulullah (sallallahu
alayhi wasallam) has stated the principle to be the
SIGHTING of the hilaal. The scheme to substitute the
principle of sighting the hilaal with the 'birth' of the
moon is, therefore, tantamount to the rejection of the
ruling declared by Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi
wasallam).
Specifically
refuting
the
validity
of
scientific
methodology for commencing Ramadhaan and Eid,
Rasulullah (Sallallahu alayhi wasallam) emphasized:
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
11
“Verily, we are an unlettered community
(ummatan ummiyatan). We neither write nor
calculate. The month is so much and so much and
so much, i.e. sometimes it is 29 days and
sometimes it is 30 days."
When Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam)
said: "so much and much and so much" he
indicated with the fingers of both hands the third
time he folded one thumb to indicate 29 days.
(Bukhaari Shareef)
This simple method of actual hilaal-sighting, 29 days or
30 days was ordered by Rasulullah (Sallallahu alayhi
wasallam) in an era when astronomy had gained
ascendency and when future eclipses of the moon / sun
could be predicted with precision. Despite this fact,
Rasulullah (Sallallahu alayhi wasallam) stated the
Islamic principle of Rooyat or 30 days. The implication
of refuting the validity of scientific methods for this
purpose will not be hidden to people of Aql (sound,
Islamic intelligence).
The universal calendar and Ramadhaan/Eid on one day
global theory is in conflict with the Ijma’ of the Ahlus
Sunnah Wal Jama’ah which in this era comprises of
only the Four Math-habs. In terms of the principles of
the Math-habs it is not possible to begin Ramadhaan and
have Eid on the same day in all places of the world. The
Shaafi’ Math-hab is emphatic in refuting the universal
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
12
calendar stunt. The following rulings explain the Shaafi’
position with clarity:
“…Verily, for every city is its ruling regarding
risings and settings, e.g. the rising and setting of
the sun, as Maawardi has said as well as others.
This is categorically stated in Al-Kifaayah as
well. . . . Thus, it is proper to relate the time of
fasting with the risings of Fajr.
Imaam Azraee said: ‘The Hadith of Kuraib is
narrated by Muslim, Abu Dawood and Tirmizi.
Kuffaal mentions it as well as those after him and
rely on him. And, the practice according to the
majority of Ulama is on it (the Hadith of Kuraib).
It is correct and the proof is with it. It is the
statement of the Fuqaha among the Taabieen.
Imaam Usnawi states in Sharhul Minhaaj: ‘The-
re is no doubt that the specific Nass, viz., the
Hadith of Kuraib, pertains to Shaam and Hijaaz.
In it are to be found the factors of masaafatul
qasr (the distance when Qasr Salaat has to be
performed), ikhtilaaful aqleem (difference in
regional zones), ikhtilaaful mataali' (difference of
horizons), and the possibility of non-sighting (in
regard to different places). Every group has
adopted one of these (factors) and has taken its
support from the Hadith of Kuraib.'
Imaam Azraee said: ‘It (this view) is well-known
by us (Shaafi's). The Jamhoor (i.e. the majority of
the Shaaf'i Fuqaha) have authenticated that for
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
13
every city is its (own) sighting. Raaf'i and
Nawawi too have authenticated it. And, Allah
Subhaanahu wa Ta'ala knows best. . .”
(Al-Fataawal Kubra)
According to the Shaafi’ Math-hab, the factors of
Ikhtilaaful Mataali’ and Masaafatus Safar are vital in
the determination of the beginning of Ramadhaan and
Eid. Only deviates such as the bunch of miscreant
‘scholars’ who converged in Istanbul are ignorant of the
Ijma’ and valid differences of the Four Math-habs
which may not be ignored or discarded, for these Four
Math-habs constitute the inviolable Shariah of Allah
Azza Wa Jal Who commands in the Qur’aan Majeed:
“Then, We have established you on a Shariah
regarding affairs (all affairs). Therefore, follow it, and
do not follow the vain desires of those who know not (of
the juhala who submit the Deen to their wayward
opinions of the nafs).”
(Surah Jaathiyah, Aayat 18)
The purpose of the phases of the moon is to enable
every community to determine and establish the Ahkaam
related to the sighting and phases of the hilaal. Thus, the
Qur’aan states:
“They ask you (O Muhammad!) about the hilaal (its
phases- its waxing and waning). Tell them that it is (a
calculation of) time for the people and for Hajj.”
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
14
In response to this request of some Sahaabah, this Aayat
was revealed. The phases of the moon are for
calculating, time, the months, the Hajj season, the Iddat
of women, etc. The waxing and waning of the moon is
for assisting Muslims in these matters which are
dependent on the physical sighting of the moon, not on
scientific calculations. Furthermore, the differences in
the resultant dates are just logical. Uniformity for the
entire world in these issues is neither practical nor
among the objectives of the Shariah. The Shariah has
not placed this burden on the Ummah.
These calculations are meant for the entire Ummah
whether scientist or village dweller. Scientific expertise
does not feature in this issue which applies to each and
every Muslims regardless of his knowledge or
ignorance. The ahkaam of Islam were revealed for the
whole of mankind – for the educated and the illiterate,
for the city sweller and the rustic, for the scientist and
the nomad in the desert, for those who live in cities,
towns, villages, islands, on mountains and in deserts.
The laws of the Deen are not subservient to intricate
mathematical, astronomical and scientific calculations
and determinations. The fulfilment of the commands
of the Shariah has been rendered easy by Allah Ta’ala
for all and sundry, and it is not a subject for stupid
world conferences of stupid ‘scholars’ who converge
in halls and hotels to eat and excrete at the expense of
the money of the ignorant masses. These juhala
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
15
‘scholars’ are on conference jaunts for nothing but
merrymaking.
These wayward ‘scholars’ have no serious work nor do
they understand the Maqsad (Objective) of life on earth,
hence they have time for frolicking, merrymaking and
jetting around the world squandering millions of dollars
of the Ummah’s money to engage in drivel conferences,
stupidly arguing issues which were settled by Divine
Decree more than fourteen centuries ago. They conduct
themselves as if Ramadhaan, Eid and Hilaal issues are
developments of this belated age, 14 centuries after the
advent of Nubuwwat.
Whilst the Ummah is suffering in every walk of life –
poverty, ignorance and oppression, and grovelling in
fisq, fujoor, bid’ah and even kufr, these miscreant
‘scholars’ congregating in luxury and waste derive
pleasure in merrymaking. Their conferences are nothing
but gatherings where they blow a lot of hot air and
disgorge hogwash. This conference to plot a uniform
Islamic calendar was an affair for clowns. It is devoid of
Islamic veracity and validity. It is bereft of goodness.
The nomads wandering in the deserts and the rustics in
their villages understand hilaal issues better then these
‘academic’ morons whose profession is to vomit flotsam
in the name of Islam.
Just imagine! Convening conference upon conference
for years and assembling scores of moron ‘scholars’
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
16
whose dilettantish attitude and socialism render them
person’a non grata in terms of the Shariah. Their
dissertations
are
bunkum.
They
are
simply
a
conglomeration of insoforia which are a disgrace to
Islam. They accord their excrescent views and baseless
opinions greater value than the ahkaam of the Shariah.
They suffer from moon madness, hence they quibble
about the moon fourteen centuries after Rasulullah
(Sallallahu alayhi wasallam) had stated the simple rules
applicable to the commencement of Ramadhaan and
Eid.
With their subjective opinions heavily influenced by the
kufr liberalism of westernism, they seek to remould the
Shariah to conform to their egocentric attitudes which
have no truck with the Deen. Consider the NNB
Jamiat’s participation in this nonsensical conference.
They squandered tens of thousands of rands of public,
Lillah funds to go for a holiday to Turkey to eat, make
merry and excrete. What did they achieve from the silly
conference of clowns? They are fully cognizant of the
mood in South Africa. The Ulama-e-Haqq here will not
submit to any stupid universal calendar faked by any
group of liberal sheikhs and molvis.
Goodness should not be read into the objective and
resolutions of the conference by the participation of
‘scholars’ from fifty countries. A venture will have
value only if it conforms with the Shariah. But this
conglomerate of liberals and wayward ‘scholars’ have
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
17
no Shar’i platform. They raise their structure purely on
the basis of opinion. It is ludicrous for so many people
to travel from 50 countries, squandering millions of
dollars of public funds acquired in dubious and haraam
ways to discuss a simple mas’alah which was decided
and concluded Divinely more than fourteen centuries
ago.
The attitude being publicized is to create the perception
of a new mas’alah which had not existed in Islam, and
which is the effect of science and modernity. These
moron ‘scholars’ are involved in haraam from the very
time they leave their homes with the intention of
participating in a copro-conference devoid of Shar’i
reality. They are embroiled in unnecessary haraam
intermingling of sexes from the time they leave home.
Their conference is in western kuffaar style. The food
they gluttonously gobble is carrion, haraam and
mushtabah, and served in utensils from which haraam
was served to kuffaar. They devour their carrion food in
haraam western style. They use western toilets where
observing proper Istinja is problematic. In fact, most of
these ‘scholars’ are such westernized liberals who lack
expertise in the Shar’i methodology of Istinja. They
stand and urinate like asses. Their conception of
Tahaarat is decidedly western. They sleep in hotel beds
in which zina is committed.
They answer the stupid invitation of a stupid
government which has no valid relationship with Islam.
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
18
The funding is haraam. The Turkish governmental
agency which has organized the stupid conference to
discuss a mas’alah which is found in even elementary
Madrasah text books, is funded with the haraam money
of the state – money acquired by means of haraam
taxation.
This entire escapade is nothing other than a holiday for
merrymaking in haraam ways, squandering public funds
whilst millions of the Ummah are languishing in heart-
rending suffering. They are bereft of shame and
understanding.
Ramadhaan and Eid have been in the Ummah for more
than 14 centuries. Muslims are in no need of the silly
prescriptions of the miscreant, modernist and deviate
‘scholars’ of the nafs whose only motivation is hub-e-
jah (love for fame) and hub-e-maal (love for the dollars).
A fitting description of the moron ‘scholars’ whose
occupation is merrymaking conferences where only hot
air is blown, is the Qur’aanic aayat:
“And, among people is he who dispute about Allah
(about His Laws) without (sound) knowledge, and he
follows every rebellious shaitaan.”
Global moon-sighting is an alien concept. It has no
validity in the Shariah. A universal calendar is an
impractical stupidity having no Shar’i validity. The
GLOBAL MOON-SIGHTING
19
only valid method for determining the Islamic months is
the principle of Rooyat (seeing the moon with the naked
eyes) or having a 30 day month in the event of the moon
not being sighted.
It is a legitimate Islamic practice for every place to
determine the commencement of its own Ramadhaan
and Eid days. There is no Shar’i incumbency to accept
the sighting of another city, town, country, etc. The
controversies created regarding the hilaal are the effects
of ignorance. Following the Shariah never gives rise to
moon-madness.
Reproduced from https://themajlis.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/books_global-moon-sighting.pdf